resources

Stem-Cell Niches in Aging: The Microenvironments That Shape Tissue Renewal

Five distinct regulatory tasks define stem-cell niches across major tissues, illustrating how microenvironmental aging and signaling breakdown alter regenerative capacity over time.

Stem-Cell Niches in Aging: The Microenvironments That Shape Tissue Renewal
Share
PinterestFacebookLinkedInRedditTelegramX
October 1, 2026
Biology of Aging & Longevity Science

A small cut on the finger or a pulled muscle heals in days during youth. Decades later, that same minor injury can linger for weeks, leaving behind stiff scar tissue. For a long time, the standard explanation was simple: resident stem cells had simply worn out, depleted their divisions, or died off.

Modern longevity science paints a much more complex picture. Stem cells do not operate in a vacuum. Instead, they live inside specialized microenvironments known as stem-cell niches. These local environments dictate when stem cells rest, when they divide, and what kind of tissue they create.

When tissues lose their regenerative capacity with age, the blame rarely falls on stem cells alone. Often, the niche itself undergoes remodeling, sending altered signals or failing to provide physical and metabolic support. Understanding this dynamic microenvironment is central to understanding how tissues age.

Researchers studying cellular and metabolic longevity have found that the relationship between a stem cell and its local home is two-way. An aged microenvironment can suppress a healthy, functional stem cell. Conversely, a supportive environment can sometimes coax older cells into mounting effective tissue repair.

This guide examines the biological architecture of stem-cell niches across major organ systems. It explores the molecular signals that govern regeneration, reviews what experimental models show, and details the critical boundaries of current evidence.

How Stem Cell Niches Coordinate Tissue Renewal

A stem-cell niche is an active, highly organized anatomical unit. It consists of supporting stromal cells, extracellular matrix scaffolds, blood vessels, nerve endings, and immune cells. Together, these elements supply the physical anchorage and biochemical cues required to sustain tissue renewal throughout life.

  • SYSTEMIC ENVIRONMENT
  • (Circulating hormones, nutrients, inflammatory cues)
  • LOCAL STEM-CELL NICHE
  • Neighboring support cells (stromal, Paneth, glial)
  • Extracellular matrix (collagen, laminin, stiffness)
  • Local vasculature & oxygen gradients
  • Sympathetic nerve inputs & resident immune cells
  • STEM CELL
  • Quiescence vs. Activation
  • Self-Renewal vs. Differentiation
  • Intrinsic genomic & metabolic state

Rather than serving as a passive docking bay, the niche performs five distinct regulatory tasks:

  • Quiescence maintenance: It keeps stem cells in a dormant, non-dividing state to protect them from metabolic stress and DNA replication errors.
  • Controlled activation: It delivers rapid, synchronized signals that prompt cells to enter the cell cycle when an injury occurs.
  • Self-renewal balance: It ensures that an activated stem cell divides into at least one new stem cell, preserving the pool.
  • Differentiation guidance: It steers daughter cells down specific developmental trajectories to replace lost cell types.
  • Physical protection: It shields stem cells from external shear stress, pathogen exposure, and toxic metabolites.

Tissue homeostasis depends on a three-way dialogue between the intrinsic state of the stem cell, the local niche architecture, and the systemic circulation. Systemic factors like circulating hormones, nutritional status, and inflammatory molecules wash over the niche. The local microenvironment filters and translates these broader organismal cues for the stem cell.

When an injury occurs, surrounding stromal cells release localized growth factors while the extracellular matrix remodels to allow cellular migration. Endothelial cells in nearby capillaries dilate to deliver oxygen, glucose, and circulating immune cells. Once repair finishes, the niche restores inhibitory cues, ordering the remaining stem cells back into deep quiescence.

Because this system relies on precise balance, even minor changes in niche composition can degrade tissue function. If the niche sends too few activation signals, tissues atrophy from lack of replacement cells. If it sends continuous activation signals without rest periods, the stem-cell pool risks exhaustion or malignant transformation.

Cell-Intrinsic Decline Versus Microenvironmental Remodeling

Scientific debates in geroscience frequently contrast cell-intrinsic aging with cell-extrinsic aging. Intrinsic aging refers to damage that accumulates inside the stem cell itself, such as telomere shortening, somatic DNA mutations, mitochondrial dysfunction, and epigenetic drift. Extrinsic aging refers to changes that occur outside the cell, within the niche or systemic circulation.

In real biological systems, tissue decline represents a continuous interaction between both processes. An intrinsically damaged stem cell cannot function normally even in a pristine environment. At the same time, a structurally damaged niche can paralyze a stem cell that remains biologically competent.

A central mistake in popular discussions is viewing niche aging as a simple depletion of helpful factors. Aging microenvironments do not merely run out of nourishing proteins. Instead, they actively remodel into restrictive, dysregulated states.

Age-related niche remodeling involves several concrete structural and biochemical changes:

  • Extracellular matrix stiffening: Collagen cross-linking and aberrant matrix deposition alter the physical tension felt by stem cells, disrupting mechanical signaling pathways.
  • Cellular composition shifts: Stromal support cells can senesce, convert into fat cells, or lose their baseline functional identity.
  • Vascular rarefaction: Microvessels regress, reducing local blood flow and creating irregular oxygen and nutrient gradients.
  • Persistent inflammatory signaling: Chronic low-grade inflammation, often called inflammaging, floods the niche with disruptive cytokines.
  • Senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP): Senescent support cells secrete matrix-degrading enzymes and inflammatory factors that degrade the local architecture.

This remodeling means an aged niche delivers incorrect instructions rather than remaining silent. It may provide chronic, low-level stress signals while failing to deliver the sharp, high-amplitude bursts of growth factors needed for injury repair.

Understanding this distinction is vital for biology of aging and longevity science. If tissue aging were solely caused by irreversible stem-cell loss, regenerative medicine would require complete cell replacement. Because microenvironmental remodeling plays a major role, modifying local signaling cues remains an active and promising area of preclinical investigation.

Skeletal Muscle: Satellite Cells, Notch Signaling, and Systemic Cues

Skeletal muscle provides one of the clearest experimental windows into niche dynamics. Adult muscle regeneration depends on muscle stem cells known as satellite cells. These cells reside in an anatomically distinct niche wedged between the muscle fiber membrane (the sarcolemma) and the surrounding basal lamina sheath.

Under normal conditions, adult satellite cells remain in deep quiescence. When mechanical trauma or exercise damages a muscle fiber, satellite cells activate, proliferate rapidly, and fuse with the damaged fiber or with each other to build new muscle tissue.

The primary molecular switch controlling this activation is the Notch signaling pathway. In young muscle, injury triggers niche cells and activating satellite cells to upregulate Delta-family ligands. These ligands bind to Notch receptors on adjacent satellite cells, releasing the Notch intracellular domain to drive cell-cycle entry and prevent premature differentiation.

In aged muscle, this activation cascade falters. Studies in aged mice demonstrate that injured muscle fails to upregulate Delta ligands effectively, leaving Notch dormant. Concurrently, inhibitory signaling pathways like TGF-beta/SMAD3 increase within the niche, blocking the cellular machinery needed for muscle progenitor expansion.

Human muscle biopsies tell a complementary story. Research shows that older adults often retain a substantial pool of satellite cells within their basal lamina niches. However, these retained cells fail to activate and proliferate when muscle attrition occurs, reflecting an uncoupling of stem-cell presence from regenerative competence.

Skeletal muscle also served as the primary model for heterochronic parabiosis experiments, where researchers surgically joined the circulatory systems of young and old mice. When an old mouse was exposed to young systemic blood, its aged satellite cells upregulated Delta, restored Notch signaling, and repaired damaged muscle fibers far more effectively.

Importantly, tracking studies showed that the newly regenerated muscle fibers were formed by the old mouse's own resident stem cells, not by young cells migrating through the shared bloodstream. Exposure to serum from young animals reproduced this effect in cell culture dishes in a Notch-dependent manner.

These muscle studies demonstrate that aged stem cells can retain latent functional capacity that is suppressed by their local and systemic environment. Yet, while these findings provide crucial mechanistic insights, they do not prove that systemic rejuvenation is a simple, ready-to-use therapy for human muscle loss.

Bone Marrow: Hematopoietic Niches, Lineage Skewing, and Inflammaging

The bone marrow harbors hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), which are responsible for generating every blood and immune cell in the body. The bone marrow cavity represents one of the most complex multicellular niches in mammalian biology.

The hematopoietic niche is not a single structure. It is an intricate, three-dimensional network composed of:

  • Sinusoidal and arteriolar endothelial cells: Specialized blood vessels that control HSC trafficking, quiescence, and oxygen exposure.
  • Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs): Connective tissue cells that secrete critical retention factors like CXCL12 and stem cell factor (SCF).
  • Osteoblasts and osteoclasts: Bone-lining cells that help structure the endosteal surface.
  • Sympathetic nerve fibers: Autonomic nerves with non-myelinating Schwann cells that regulate circadian release of stem cells.
  • Bone marrow adipocytes: Fat cells that expand with age and alter local metabolic signaling.
  • Resident macrophages: Immune cells that help anchor HSCs and clear cellular debris.

As bone marrow ages, hematopoietic output changes significantly. The system exhibits reduced overall regenerative capacity, decreased per-cell repopulation efficiency, and marked myeloid skewing. Older marrow overproduces myeloid cells (granulocytes and monocytes) while producing fewer lymphoid cells (B and T lymphocytes), contributing to weakened adaptive immunity.

Microenvironmental remodeling in the marrow drives much of this transformation. With age, the marrow cavity accumulates adipocytes and experiences vascular changes, including loss of specialized arteriolar vessels. Mesenchymal stromal cells alter their differentiation preferences, showing a bias toward adipogenesis rather than osteogenesis.

Inflammaging plays a pronounced role in bone marrow decline. Chronic exposure to systemic inflammatory signals like IL-6, TNF-alpha, and IL-1 alters the behavior of stromal support cells. These inflamed niche cells downregulate supportive retention signals, driving HSCs out of quiescence and promoting chronic, low-level proliferation that degrades their self-renewal capacity.

Reciprocal transplantation experiments in mice illustrate the balance of power between HSCs and their niche. When young HSCs are transplanted into aged, irradiated bone marrow niches, their homing efficiency decreases, and their output becomes skewed toward myeloid lineages. Conversely, when aged HSCs are placed into a young bone marrow environment, their homing and repopulation abilities show partial, measurable improvements.

The word "partial" is essential here. While a young marrow niche improves certain functional readouts of old HSCs, it does not erase all age-related defects. Aged HSCs still carry accumulated somatic mutations and epigenetic marks that restrict their performance, demonstrating that extrinsic support and intrinsic health operate together.

Intestinal Crypts and Brain: Localized Signaling and Neurovascular Niches

Different tissues rely on distinct niche architectures to meet their specific physiological demands. Examining the intestinal lining, the central nervous system, and the skin reveals how localized signaling networks adapt or fail over time.

The Intestinal Crypt: Wnt Signaling and Paneth Cell Support

The intestinal epithelium is the fastest-renewing tissue in mammals, completely replacing its surface layer every few days. This rapid turnover is driven by intestinal stem cells (ISCs) located at the bottom of microscopic pits called crypts of Lieberkuhn.

ISCs sit directly adjacent to Paneth cells in the small intestine and are surrounded by subepithelial mesenchymal cells. These supporting neighbors supply essential canonical Wnt ligands, particularly Wnt3, alongside Notch ligands and epidermal growth factor (EGF). Wnt signaling is the mandatory biochemical engine for crypt proliferation and maintenance.

With advancing age, intestinal renewal slows, and mucosal barrier repair becomes sluggish following infection or chemotherapy. Preclinical investigations show that Paneth cells and crypt mesenchyme in aged animals produce lower amounts of Wnt3. Furthermore, aged ISCs themselves show reduced baseline Wnt signaling activity.

In laboratory organoid assays, crypt cells isolated from aged mice and humans form fewer, smaller 3D mini-gut structures compared to young controls. However, adding exogenous WNT3a to the culture medium significantly restores organoid formation efficiency in aged tissue samples.

Activating canonical downstream Wnt effectors like beta-catenin and ASCL2 similarly enhances aged organoid growth. This confirms that the aged intestinal stem cell retains the molecular machinery to respond to renewal signals when local microenvironmental deficits are bypassed.

The Brain: Neurovascular and Glial Niches

In the adult mammalian brain, neural stem cells (NSCs) persist primarily in two neurogenic zones: the subventricular zone (SVZ) lining the lateral ventricles and the subgranular zone (SGZ) of the hippocampal dentate gyrus. These niches regulate adult neurogenesis, which contributes to olfactory processing, memory formation, and neural plasticity.

The neural stem-cell niche relies heavily on a specialized neurovascular architecture. NSCs extend cellular processes that directly contact the basal lamina of local blood vessels while communicating with astrocytes, ependymal cells, and microglia.

During aging, the neural niche undergoes extensive structural regression:

  • Vascular remodeling: Capillary networks in the SVZ decrease in density and branching, accompanied by reduced local microvascular blood flow.
  • Microglial activation: Resident immune cells shift toward a chronically activated, pro-inflammatory state, producing cytokines that suppress neurogenesis.
  • Endothelial signal alterations: Aged brain endothelial cells increase production of inhibitory factors like TGF-beta, which can drive NSCs into apoptosis or permanent arrest via SMAD3 phosphorylation.

These microenvironmental changes create an antineurogenic landscape that locks remaining NSCs into deep, unproductive quiescence. Inflammatory signaling cascades within the aged cerebrospinal fluid and local vascular wall actively suppress the proliferative signals needed to generate new functional neurons.

Skin and Hair Follicles: Dermal Remodeling

Hair follicle stem cells (HFSCs) reside in the follicular bulge region of the skin, oscillating through cyclical phases of growth (anagen), regression (catagen), and rest (telogen). The dermal papilla, a cluster of specialized mesenchymal cells at the base of the follicle, acts as the primary niche signaling center.

Skin aging leads to hair thinning, delayed wound closure, and follicle miniaturization. Direct cell-transplantation experiments in rodents have tested the source of this decline.

When researchers combine aged HFSCs with neonatal dermal cells and graft them in vivo, the young dermal cells can stimulate robust hair follicle regeneration from the aged stem cells. In contrast, when young HFSCs are paired with aged dermal cells, hair follicle formation is severely blunted.

The dermal niche demonstrates that surrounding stromal cells dictate the timing and success of tissue growth cycles. Physical ECM remodeling, altered growth factor secretion, and dermal fibroblast senescence work together to constrain epithelial stem-cell behavior in aging skin.

What Experimental Models Measure Versus Clinical Realities

Evaluating longevity research requires distinguishing laboratory readouts from human health outcomes. Preclinical stem-cell research relies on a continuum of experimental models, each with distinct capabilities and limitations.

  • EVIDENCE HIERARCHY
  • 1. In Vitro & Organoid Assays (Cellular response, 3D growth)
  • 2. Animal Transplantation Models (Engraftment, homing)
  • 3. Heterochronic Parabiosis (Systemic factor screening)
  • 4. Human Tissue Biopsies (Observational signaling states)
  • 5. Controlled Clinical Trials (Human safety and efficacy)

Evidence Stage Breakdown

The current body of evidence surrounding stem-cell niches sits primarily across three distinct stages:

  • In vitro and organoid cultures: These models isolate stem cells and specific support cells in controlled dishes. They are ideal for identifying single receptor-ligand interactions, such as adding WNT3a to crypt cultures. However, they lack immune interactions, vascular perfusion, and systemic hormonal variability.
  • Rodent transplantation and parabiosis: These whole-animal models prove that microenvironments can causally alter stem-cell performance in vivo. They show that blood-borne or niche-specific signals alter tissue repair in living mice. However, rodent stem-cell niches have different telomere dynamics, metabolic rates, and lifespans compared to human niches.
  • Human observational biopsies: These studies analyze muscle, skin, or bone marrow samples taken from young and old donors. They confirm that signaling alterations observed in animals, such as blunted Notch activation or marrow adiposity, also correlate with aging in humans. However, these observational snapshots cannot prove causality or test experimental interventions directly.

Endpoints Measured

Scientific papers in this field measure precise biological endpoints rather than general longevity. Common laboratory endpoints include:

  • Colony-forming unit (CFU) capacity: The number of cell colonies generated in a culture dish.
  • Homing and engraftment efficiency: The percentage of transplanted stem cells that successfully navigate to and seed an empty bone marrow niche.
  • Lineage reconstitution ratios: The balance of myeloid versus lymphoid cells produced after marrow transplantation.
  • Organoid budding frequency: The structural complexity and survival rate of 3D mini-tissue cultures.
  • Cell-cycle marker expression: The presence of proteins like Ki-67 or phosphorylated histone H3, indicating active cell division.

A common pitfall is treating an improvement in a surrogate marker as proof of whole-body rejuvenation. Demonstrating that WNT3a increases the size of an intestinal organoid in a hydrogel matrix is a major mechanistic finding. However, it does not mean that taking a Wnt-activating supplement will safely improve human digestive health or extend lifespan.

Translating niche science requires identifying the specific physiological trade-offs involved in manipulating cell-signaling pathways inside complex human tissues.

What the Current Science Does Not Show

The discovery that microenvironments shape stem-cell aging has generated intense public interest. Unfortunately, this enthusiasm often leads to exaggerated claims that misinterpret early laboratory findings. Grounded interpretation requires acknowledging what the scientific literature has not established.

1. Young Blood Is Not a Proven Clinical Therapy

The finding that heterochronic parabiosis can activate old satellite cells in mice does not mean that human plasma transfusions are safe, effective anti-aging treatments. Parabiosis involves continuous, whole-organism circulatory sharing, including the continuous metabolic filtration provided by young kidneys, lungs, and livers.

Single or intermittent plasma infusions in humans do not replicate this experimental setup. Furthermore, unvalidated systemic blood-sharing approaches carry significant clinical risks, including severe immunological reactions, pathogen transmission, and transfusion-related acute lung injury.

2. Stem-Cell Exhaustion Is Not Universally Caused by Cell Loss

A widespread myth assumes that older adults suffer from tissue decline because their bodies have run out of stem cells entirely. While stem-cell depletion occurs in certain specific tissues, human muscle and hair follicle studies reveal that quiescent stem-cell pools are frequently maintained in normal numbers. The primary defect in these tissues is an inability to activate, proliferate, and differentiate when needed, driven by inhibitory niche signals.

3. Niche Rejuvenation Does Not Erase Genomic Mutations

Providing an aged stem cell with an optimal, youthful microenvironment does not repair its internal DNA damage. Over decades of life, human stem cells accumulate somatic mutations, chromosomal rearrangements, and telomeric attrition.

While a young niche can restore proliferative drive, forcing heavily mutated stem cells to divide more frequently carries a serious biological hazard: it can elevate the risk of clonal expansion and malignant transformation, particularly in tissues like bone marrow and the intestinal lining.

4. Over-the-Counter Supplements Cannot Reconstruct Niches

Commercial products often claim to "boost your natural stem cells" or "rejuvenate stem-cell niches" using herbal extracts, amino acid blends, or unregulated peptides. No rigorous, placebo-controlled human trial has demonstrated that any dietary supplement can remodel an aged stem-cell niche, restore vascular density, or normalize Notch and Wnt signaling cascades in human organs.

Readers interested in the practical evaluation of emerging longevity claims can review our editorial standards on longevity interventions and therapeutics.

  • MISCONCEPTION VS. REALITY
  • Claim: Aging means stem cells are completely gone.
  • Reality: Stem-cell numbers are often preserved; activation
  • and differentiation cues are impaired.
  • Claim: Rebuilding the niche reverses all cellular aging.
  • Reality: Intrinsic DNA damage and mutations remain even in
  • supportive microenvironments.
  • Claim: Systemic "youth factors" provide an easy fix.
  • Reality: Signals are tissue-specific; activating growth
  • pathways broadly can increase cancer risk.

Biomarkers and Indicators of Niche Health

Because stem-cell niches sit deep within tissues, directly monitoring their health in living humans remains technically challenging. Researchers and clinicians rely on a mix of local biopsy analyses and indirect systemic surrogate markers to evaluate niche integrity.

Tissue-Specific Structural Indicators

Direct assessment of niche architecture requires tissue biopsies, which are usually restricted to accessible organs like skeletal muscle, skin, and bone marrow. Key structural markers evaluated under microscopy include:

  • Basal lamina integrity: The thickness and biochemical organization of laminin and type IV collagen sheaths around muscle fibers.
  • Vascular proximity: The physical distance between resident stem cells and the nearest CD31-positive endothelial capillary.
  • Extracellular matrix cross-linking: Accumulation of advanced glycation end-products (AGEs) and collagen dense packing that increases tissue stiffness.
  • Local senescence markers: The presence of p16INK4a, p21, and senescence-associated beta-galactosidase within neighboring stromal cells.

Systemic and Circulating Surrogates

Measuring the broader environment that influences stem-cell niches often relies on blood-based assays. While these markers do not measure a single local niche directly, they reflect systemic pressures known to degrade microenvironmental support:

  • Inflammatory panels: High-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hs-CRP), interleukin-6 (IL-6), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha). Elevated baseline levels correlate with chronic niche stress and marrow inflammaging.
  • Circulating growth factors: Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) levels, which, when persistently elevated, associate with tissue fibrosis and satellite-cell inhibition.
  • Immune cell distribution: The ratio of circulating myeloid cells (neutrophils, monocytes) to lymphoid cells (T and B cells). A persistent myeloid skew often reflects aging within the hematopoietic bone marrow niche.

Understanding how these indicators connect to broader human health requires examining validated age, biomarkers and diagnostics rather than unvalidated direct-to-consumer testing panels.

Key Scientific Terminology

  • Stem-Cell Niche: The specialized local tissue microenvironment that anchors, protects, and regulates the behavior of resident stem cells through physical and biochemical signals.
  • Quiescence: A reversible, non-dividing cellular resting state (G0 phase of the cell cycle) that preserves stem-cell longevity and limits metabolic stress.
  • Heterochronic Parabiosis: An experimental surgical model in which the circulatory systems of a young animal and an old animal are conjoined to study the effects of shared systemic factors.
  • Paneth Cells: Specialized secretory epithelial cells located at the base of small intestinal crypts that produce antimicrobial peptides and supply essential Wnt ligands to neighboring stem cells.
  • Mesenchymal Stromal Cells (MSCs): Multipotent connective tissue cells found in bone marrow and other organs that provide structural support, secrete growth factors, and differentiate into bone, cartilage, or fat.
  • Inflammaging: A state of chronic, low-grade, sterile inflammation that develops during aging and disrupts tissue homeostasis, stromal cell function, and stem-cell maintenance.
  • Myeloid Skewing: An age-associated shift in hematopoietic stem-cell differentiation that favors the production of granulocytes and monocytes over adaptive immune lymphocytes.
  • Senescence-Associated Secretory Phenotype (SASP): A collection of pro-inflammatory cytokines, chemokines, and matrix metalloproteinases secreted by senescent cells that remodels and degrades the surrounding tissue microenvironment.

When to Revisit This Resource

The biology of stem-cell niches is advancing rapidly as single-cell transcriptomics, spatial proteomics, and organ-on-a-chip technologies mature. Readers should revisit this resource when:

  • New human clinical trials publish results testing localized therapies designed to clear senescent niche cells or remodel fibrotic matrix architecture.
  • Translational studies identify safe, tissue-targeted methods to modulate pathways like Notch, Wnt, or TGF-beta without altering systemic cancer risk.
  • Diagnostic technologies develop non-invasive, validated biomarkers capable of tracking organ-specific stem-cell niche health in clinical practice.

Tissue renewal in aging is governed by an ongoing dialogue between stem cells and the microenvironments that support them.

Recognizing that aging involves active niche remodeling, rather than simple stem-cell exhaustion, clarifies both the real challenges and the credible scientific avenues shaping longevity research.

Sources

  1. Inflamm-Aging of Hematopoiesis, Hematopoietic Stem Cells, and the ...
  2. Loss of stem cell regenerative capacity within aged niches - PMC
  3. Inflammation and Aging of Hematopoietic Stem Cells in Their Niche
  4. Stem Cells, Their Niches and the Systemic Environment: An Aging Network
  5. Aging and stem cell renewal - StemBook - NCBI Bookshelf - NIH
  6. Aging of intestinal stem cells00092-3)
  7. Intestinal stem cells: guardians of homeostasis in health ...
  8. Aging of the hematopoietic stem cells niche
  9. Tissue resident stem cells: till death do us part
  10. Aging of hair follicle stem cells and their niche - Springer Nature
keep reading

Longevity research changes faster than the headlines

Follow AgeAmaze for careful reporting on what longevity science can show today and what still needs stronger evidence.

read the Blog
Woman reading health research at a table in natural daylight